CRANBOURNE STAR NEWS
Home » Holt candidates “short-changing themselves” says politics expert

Holt candidates “short-changing themselves” says politics expert

Early voting for 21 May’s Federal Election is now open and yet voters in Holt have grounds to feel unsure about where to direct their vote.

Of the eight candidates contesting the seat vacated by the retiring Labor MP Anthony Byrne, two are proving incredibly difficult for both Star News and voters to contact or learn more about.

The candidates under the microscope are Independent Ravi Ragupathy and One Nation’s Sandra Ambard.

Senior lecturer in Politics and International Relations at Monash University, Dr Zareh Ghazarian said their inactivity is often a reflection on their party.

“If they’re not presenting, constituents don’t have that same opportunity to familiarise themselves with the candidate,” Dr Ghazarian said.

“It’s a case of parties short-changing themselves. They’re had same amount of time to prepare as other candidates.

“Minor parties face significant challenges in mobilising human and financial resources. They’re not as well-resourced, so they’re always going to struggle to get candidates and materials organised.”

Mr Ragupathy has the prized top-spot on the ballot paper, crucial in securing the ‘donkey vote’, where voters list preferences one to eight in order of how it is presented on the voting card.

A link to his website listed on his Facebook page, which is under a different name, in Tamilmurasu Ragupathy, takes you to a site currently “under construction”.

That page is updated regularly, however Twitter and Instagram accounts in his name have not posted since March 2018.

Mr Ragupathy also ran in the 2018 State Election as an independent in Pauline Richards’ seat of Cranbourne, securing 0.3 per cent of the electorate’s first preference votes.

While Ms Ambard, representing Pauline Hanson’s One Nation, has no social media presence and a blank profile on One Nation’s website, as of Tuesday 10 May, with no photo or biography provided.

Mr Ghazraian posited that this may be a deliberate decision by the party based on previous voting patterns.

“One Nation doesn’t do traditionally well in Victoria so they may be making a more tactical decision to focus on stronger areas,” he said.

One Nation has experienced controversy in recent weeks after reports into standing alleged ‘ghost candidates’ with no traceable online presence or connection to an electoral seat they are standing in.

In the case of Ms Ambard, she also lives interstate, with the Australian Electoral Commission confirming her address as in Westcourt, Cairns.

Living outside of the area is within election rules but it does question the ability of the candidate to best represent their constituents.

Despite the retirement of Mr Byrne after admitting to branch-stacking and misusing Commonwealth-funded staff, which clouded the end of his lengthy term, Dr Ghazarian is expecting a “safe” hold for the ALP.

“Long-term MPs build a following. Part of vote will be affected by Byrne’s retirement but the resilience of party vote is expected to remain.

“I wouldn’t expect it to be a seat that changes hands on election night.”

Digital Editions


  • EJ makes Masterful moves

    EJ makes Masterful moves

    Cranbourne-trainer Enver Jusufovic called in help from all quarters – New Zealand and the greyhound fraternity – to help his seven-year-old gelding Masterful win the…

More News

  • Dandenong man arrested for ATM ram raids

    Dandenong man arrested for ATM ram raids

    Two men have been arrested as police continue to investigate a series of alleged ATM ram raids across Victoria over the last two months. Detectives from the Eastern Region Crime…

  • Casey home values outpace Greater Melbourne in strongest growth since 2021

    Casey home values outpace Greater Melbourne in strongest growth since 2021

    The Casey region recorded stronger home-value growth than Greater Melbourne in 2025, according to figures by Cotality. Over the 2025 calendar year, Casey had a 6.2 per cent increase in…

  • Lions begin the big squeeze

    Lions begin the big squeeze

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 527656 Just like a teenager with pimples; a first blemish has appeared on the skin of Merinda Park (7/226) after a rejuvenated Pakenham (8/230)…

  • Bulls win in cruise control

    Bulls win in cruise control

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 527658 Reigning premier Cardinia (3/162) is fully switched on and will take a power of beating for the 2025/26 CCCA Premier Division title after…

  • Dandenong factory fire deemed suspicious

    Dandenong factory fire deemed suspicious

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 528279 A Dandenong factory caught up in flames is deemed suspicious by Victoria Police and Fire Rescue Victoria. Emergency services responded to multiple Triple…

  • Big switch on arrival for Metro Tunnel timetable

    Big switch on arrival for Metro Tunnel timetable

    The Metro Tunnel’s Big Switch timetable has been released which will integrate the new tunnel into Victoria’s train network. Minister for Public and Active Transport Gabrielle Williams released the new…

  • Clyde Road Upgrade starts 2026 strongly

    Clyde Road Upgrade starts 2026 strongly

    Major road and freeway closures will impact motorists travelling through Cranbourne and Berwick later this month, as crews push ahead with critical works on the Clyde Road Upgrade. The Princes…

  • Aussie double at Southern

    Aussie double at Southern

    Southern Golf Club in Keysborough provided the perfect canvas for the nation’s number-one ranked amateur event last week with the 2026 Australian Master of the Amateurs attracting some quality young…

  • Noble nourishment and Falcons flounder as VSDCA resumes

    Noble nourishment and Falcons flounder as VSDCA resumes

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 527661 The dawn of a new year has seen continued success for an in-form Noble Park (7/159) after a comfortable three-wicket victory over Yarraville…

  • Alleged speeding crash ends on Star News office embankment

    Alleged speeding crash ends on Star News office embankment

    Passers-by intervened as an alleged speeding car came to grief outside the Pakenham Gazette (also Star News)’s office just after 4pm on Friday 9 January. Witnesses said the dark green…