CRANBOURNE STAR NEWS
Home » Questions left unasked

Questions left unasked

Anzac100 Years 375x120

 

By BRIDGET SCOTT

WHEN Beryl Craig reflects on the time she spent with her father, she wished she had asked more.
“He didn’t talk much,” but Arthur Walter Sinclair held a soft spot for his youngest of three who he affectionately knew as ‘Scruff’.
“You remember a lot as you age – there was a lot I wished I had asked,” the Cranbourne woman said.
His quiet and reserved nature was well warranted, after he was deemed totally and permanently incapacitated (TPI) upon his return from World War I.
Young and naive at just 18 years of age, nothing could have prepared the Brunswick-born boy for what he would endure after he enlisted on 22 February 1916.
A gunner as part of the 14th Field Artillery Brigade, 2nd Reinforcements, it was over a year after he had arrived overseas that Gunner Sinclair was badly wounded and forced to spend a year in a rehabilitation centre.
In 1917 Gunner Sinclair was shot in the leg and taken to Etaples where he remained for a while before he was moved to a rehabilitation centre in a London hospital.
The injuries sustained by the soldier impacted the rest of his life and Ms Craig can remember attending ceremonies on Anzac Day with her own father unable to march.
While Ms Craig’s memories of her father’s experience overseas are scarce, she can still recall the few times he opened up to his family.
“He used to tell a story of when he was in the trenches, sitting around the fire with his fellow troops with their singlets out, trying to get rid of all the lice,” she said.
As with most families during the war, letters were exchanged from one side of the world to the other, and Ms Craig has held on to one which her father received from his own mother.
“He who laughs last laughs best,” his mother told him during a warning against giving into “temptations” while at war.
Urged not to drink by his mother, Ms Craig believes years of smoking killed her father at the young age of 67.
“He was encouraged to smoke – the effects killed him,” she said.
Prior to this her father, a qualified tuckpointer struggled to return to work after the war.
“There wasn’t a lot around, it seemed unfair,” she said.
Life was never easy for the Sinclairs, with Ms Craig herself born at the beginning of the Great Depression after her parents married.
However she will never forget her father’s quirky sense of humour which still remained intact.
Buried at Nillumbik Cemetery in Diamond Creek, her father’s service wasn’t Ms Craig’s only connection to the war.
With sadness she recalled her great uncle, Robert Hector Sinclair, who remains as one of many soldiers with no known grave. On 25 April 1915, Mrs Craig’s great uncle was killed in action.“He was 34 when he joined up and had no family,” she said.
“He had a hard life, he must have felt at the time that nobody wanted him,” she said.
Robert Sinclair is one of 3268 Australians commemorated on the Lone Pine Memorial in Turkey.
With a strong connection to WWI, Ms Craig said it was important to remember the meaning behind Anzac Day.
“It’s not a celebration, it’s a remembrance,” she said.
“What a waste it was.”

Digital Editions


  • EPA, Veolia at odds over toxic-waste cell

    EPA, Veolia at odds over toxic-waste cell

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 228738 The state’s pollution watchdog says it remains opposed to a new toxic-waste cell at a controversial hazardous-waste landfill…

More News

  • Melbourne set to take on North Melbourne in Casey Fields practice match

    Melbourne set to take on North Melbourne in Casey Fields practice match

    Local AFL fanatics are in for a treat, as Casey Fields will take centre stage when Melbourne takes on North Melbourne in a practice match bringing elite AFL action to…

  • Drunk driver sentenced for fatal, high-speed crash

    Drunk driver sentenced for fatal, high-speed crash

    A Clyde North drink driver who lost control at a Tooradin roundabout at high speed resulting in the death of his friend has been jailed for at least five-and-a-half years.…

  • What’s on

    What’s on

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 489780 CaseyGirlsCan Tennis at Hampton Park Free, coached beginner tennis sessions for Casey women, no prior skills or knowledge of tennis required. Follows the…

  • Cranbourne commuters question train reliability

    Cranbourne commuters question train reliability

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 532942 Performance data shows the Cranbourne Line has broadly tracked close to Melbourne’s network-wide averages for reliability in recent years, but commuters say delays,…

  • New rules ban interest on hardship-deferred rates

    New rules ban interest on hardship-deferred rates

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 429633 Ratepayers facing hardship are expected not to be charged interest on deferred rates under new State rules. Casey has confirmed that it already…

  • Champs, chats and chokes

    Champs, chats and chokes

    DAVE: Good morning boys, what a massive week of sport; we’ve a had a Pro-Am series through West Gippsland, the Woolamai Cup was on, Country Week has begun, and then…

  • New threatened species facility opens at Moonlit Sanctuary

    New threatened species facility opens at Moonlit Sanctuary

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 531518 Moonlit Sanctuary Wildlife Conservation Park in Pearcedale officially unveiled its new purpose-built Aquatic Fauna Conservation Facility on Tuesday 10 February. Featuring precise environmental…

  • Calls for more foster parents as crisis mounts in Victoria

    Calls for more foster parents as crisis mounts in Victoria

    Lynn, a Casey local, stumbled on a television commercial about foster care at 65 years old. Piquing her interest, the Tongan-born mother of five, decided to do some more online…

  • Former Casey Mayor diagnosed with MND

    Former Casey Mayor diagnosed with MND

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 182116 Ex two-time Casey Mayor and VFL footballer Geoff Ablett has been diagnosed with Motor Neurone Disease (MND), prompting his family to launch a…

  • Cobras strike and Maroons rally in Turf 2 action

    Cobras strike and Maroons rally in Turf 2 action

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 533005 The Dandenong District Cricket Association (DDCA) Turf 2 competition is heating up with the top three tightly contested and Parkfield holding onto top…