CRANBOURNE STAR NEWS
Home » We told you so!

We told you so!

Methane mess! Back row, left to right: Pam and Frank Jones, Terry and Barbara Fox, Jeff and Lesley White. Front row: Nathan, Sophie and Emily White. 23165 Picture: Stewart Chambers.Methane mess! Back row, left to right: Pam and Frank Jones, Terry and Barbara Fox, Jeff and Lesley White. Front row: Nathan, Sophie and Emily White. 23165 Picture: Stewart Chambers.

By Glen Atwell
SEVEN years ago, the sickening stench of decomposing rubbish was the first alarm bell that rang inside the head of Brookland Greens resident Frank Jones.
It was 2001, and Mr Jones, his wife Pam and a small group of residents, knew something was horribly wrong with the estate they nervously called home.
A ruthless and unrelenting smell emanating from the closed Stevensons Road Landfill was slowly taking over their lives.
The residents demanded action, and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) ordered landfill management to clean up its act.
But today, seven years on, the same residents are still screaming ‘We told you so!’
In 2001, the Jones’ lived in a lavish house on Huntingdale Close, but the relentless stench forced them to relocate to Eaglescliffe Crescent in 2004.
“The smell was horrific, and it never let up. It was the smell of sewerage, not normal rubbish. It forced us out of our home,” he said.
“Pam and I moved to Eaglescliffe Crescent, which is on the other side of Brookland Greens estate and as far away from the landfill as possible.”
In light of the recent methane mess, Frank admits it would have been wiser to ditch the troubled estate altogether.
“If I knew it was going to get this bad, we would have left in 2004,” he said.
“The tip was mismanaged when it was open, it was mismanaged after it closed and is still mismanaged today. In 2001, there was no methane extraction system and no water purification system. It was just an ugly hole in the ground.”
Mr Jones estimates the value of his property has already fallen 50 per cent.
“It’s a disaster. There are houses in this estate worth around $700,000. Every owner in here is facing a huge loss,” he said.
Terry Fox, an ex-neighbour of Mr Jones, said residents were promised seven years ago that things would be sorted out.
“We had meetings with the EPA and Casey Council in 2001, and were basically told to stop worrying and get on with our lives,” he said.
“My house was worth $600,000 three weeks ago and today I can’t give it away.”
The City of Casey recently announced an additional $5 million in funds to stop methane gas leaching from the landfill and begin rebuilding the broken Brookland Greens community.
Mayor Janet Halsall said the council had allocated around $10 million to the methane mess and called on the state government to commit more money to assist and support affected residents.
“Make no mistake, the damage to the community has gone far beyond the limits of the methane,” Cr Halsall said.
“There are young children who don’t want to leave their homes in case it’s not there when they get back. There are insurance and settlement issues, there are building issues, impacts on some local businesses and the list goes on.
“We must focus our efforts on rebuilding a community that has been left bruised and battered by recent events,” Cr Halsall said.

Digital Editions


  • Citizens embraced on Australia Day

    Citizens embraced on Australia Day

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 530327 Dozens of Casey’s newest citizens were welcomed in a citizenship ceremony at Bunjil Place on 26 January. There…

More News

  • Teens flee stolen-car crash on Monash Freeway

    Teens flee stolen-car crash on Monash Freeway

    Up to eight teen boys fled from a stolen car after a two-vehicle crash in Endeavour Hills on Saturday morning 24 January. The allegedly stolen white Mazda 3 was spotted…

  • Man scarred by alleged New Year’s Eve stabbing

    Man scarred by alleged New Year’s Eve stabbing

    A Hampton Park man says his “life has changed forever” after a horrifying alleged stabbing on the evening of New Years Eve at Pakenham Station. James says he remembers watching…

  • Soil clean-up wait continues

    Soil clean-up wait continues

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 522112 A giant asbestos-riddled soil mound in Bangholme’s Green Wedge still remains, despite an order for its removal by the end of 2025. In…

  • Housing plan for Berwick’s Manuka Road

    Housing plan for Berwick’s Manuka Road

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 333109 After a contentious two year dispute, a housing plan for an 18-hectare site including the historical Clover Cottage on Manuka Road, Berwick has…

  • Celebrating a good harvest

    Celebrating a good harvest

    Basking in sunshine, about 200 celebrated a Pongal harvest festival in Harmony Square, Dandenong on Sunday 18 January. Victorian Tamil Cultural Association staged the 32nd annual event, featuring drumming, dancing…