CRANBOURNE STAR NEWS
Home » Anthem decision should not divide, says Islamic Council

Anthem decision should not divide, says Islamic Council

By LACHLAN MOORHEAD

THE Islamic Council of Victoria (ICV) has called for calm in the wake of the National Anthem debate involving a Cranbourne primary school.
The ICV released an official statement on Monday in which ICV secretary Kuranda Seyit said the group did not want the incident to “divide Australians”.
“The national anthem is important to all Australians, including Muslims,” Mr Seyit said.
The ICV was responding to Cranbourne Carlisle Primary School’s decision to allow Islamic students to leave a Year 2-6 assembly to avoid singing the Australian National Anthem, citing Muharram – a religious month of mourning for Shi’a Muslims.
Over the last week, the issue has been covered on several television networks, on 3AW and ABC radio, drawn comment from opinion writers and national columnists, and even a response from Senator Jacqui Lambie and Federal Treasurer Scott Morrison.
It was also debated on the ABC’s Q and A program, and Channel Nine’s new equivalent, The Verdict.
Star News broke the story last month after Lorraine McCurdy, whose grandchildren go to the school, attended the school’s assembly and was concerned by the staff’s decision to give Muslim students the option to not sing the national anthem.
She said about “30 to 40” Muslim students left the assembly.
In its statement the ICV said the incident was a “departmental matter” and they would allow the school to deal with the issue.
“We will provide advice to the Department of Education in subsequent years, but ultimately it is their decision,” the ICV statement said.
Education Minister James Merlino last week threw his support behind the school, saying the school had shown “respect and sensitivity to the different cultures and faiths within its community”, and that the action of the students “was not a sign of disrespect”.
Cranbourne Carlisle Primary School principal Cheryl Irving said the decision was made in adherence with Muharram – the Islamic month of mourning associated with Shi’a Muslims in which they do not participate in “joyful events”.
“Muharram is a cultural observation marking the death of Imam Hussein,” Ms Irving said.
“This year it falls between Tuesday 13 October and Thursday 12 November. During this time Shi’a do not participate in joyful events as it is a period of mourning.
“This includes listening to music, attending parties, wearing nail polish or make-up, etc.
“Prior to last week’s Years 2-6 assembly commencing, an announcement was made advising anyone participating in Muharram, that it was an opportune time to leave the hall as music was about to be played (the National Anthem).
“Anyone who was unable to listen to music due to this cultural observance was given adequate time to comply with their religious belief.”

Digital Editions


More News

  • Cross realises AFL dream as Demons pick up Casey product

    Cross realises AFL dream as Demons pick up Casey product

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 499252 Consistency, persistence and belief. Those three words have defined Paddy Cross’ journey to the top level after the livewire utility was officially picked…

  • Bandits fall as Roos hop

    Bandits fall as Roos hop

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 537219 Parkfield has been on top of the DDCA Turf 2 ladder for a long time but Coomoora will now head into finals in…

  • Champs make move in highlight performance of round four

    Champs make move in highlight performance of round four

    Defending champion High 5’s has once again put its stamp on Division 1 of the Mountain Dart League after an impressive 8-2 victory in the top-of-the-table clash against Bullseyes. Both…

  • Dasun earns recognition

    Dasun earns recognition

    Dasun Opanayaka couldn’t have had a better debut season in the DDCA after moving to Springvale South and recently being crowned the 2025/26 Wookey Medallist. Actually … there is one…

  • Swans pass first pressure test with rematch on the cards

    Swans pass first pressure test with rematch on the cards

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 537210 Casey South Melbourne (130 and 182) will be hoping to reproduce its round 17 performance in Victorian Premier Cricket (VPC) this week after…

  • Noble Park locked and loaded

    Noble Park locked and loaded

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 520678 Noble Park (7/121) can begin preparations for a finals campaign in the Victorian Sub-District Cricket Association after locking down a top-six berth with…

  • Sweet taste for battling teams as things even up in SWGDL

    Sweet taste for battling teams as things even up in SWGDL

    Three teams enjoyed their first wins of the season in round three of the South West Gippsland Dart League (SWGDL) while the top-four cemented their claims as early premiership contenders.…

  • New Casey Local Law now in place

    New Casey Local Law now in place

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 429633 A refreshed Casey Local Law came into effect on 2 March. Casey Council undertook a review and community consultation on the Local Law…

  • Colours fly at Holi Festival

    Colours fly at Holi Festival

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 535616 Lynbrook Residents Association (LRA) hosted its annual Holi Festival at Banjo Paterson Park on Saturday 28 February. A spokesperson of LRA said it…

  • Land release alone won’t lower house prices, expert warns

    Land release alone won’t lower house prices, expert warns

    The Opposition’s plan to fast-track land release in growth areas is unlikely to significantly reduce house prices on its own, according to an RMIT housing expert. Associate Professor Trivess Moore,…